
As I was driving home today, I spotted Gary - last week's stranded, depressed, former church goer from a distant town. He was chatting with someone at a corner bus stop while I sat at the stoplight watching him and debating. A week ago I was taken in by his sad story and had felt at least a little superior about my generous and compassionate response. This afternoon, however, I sat through the long light, deflated and debating. Should I stop to talk with him? Wag an accusing finger at him? Ask for a refund? Call the cops?
Once a teen from church shared a similar story about helping someone he and friends had met, pooling together their money to give the stranger a few bucks for a night in a nearby shelter. Several days later, the young man was still stewing about whether he had done the right thing. (I know the feeling.) Stewing enough to come in and talk about it. What if the money was spent on alcohol or drugs? What if the stranger hadn't gone to the shelter? What if there wasn't even a shelter? Had he and his friends behaved foolishly by giving money? Could our faith make us fools? I guess the simple answer is "Yes."
The Bible has not-so-simple verses that could speak to this kind of human dilemma. For example, in the gospel of Luke Jesus urges us to "give to everyone who begs from you: and if anyone takes your goods, do not ask for them again."
(Luke 6:30) That sounds wildly generous but also unwise and irresponsible and un-doable to me. Everyone? That guy on the corner who ripped me off? Responding to enemies with love, forgiving people, turning the other cheek, turning out my pockets? Doing these things, even grudgingly and imperfectly, can makes us look like such fools by the world's standards when we'd prefer to look powerful and generous and - in my case - oh so right.
So I sat at the stoplight, fuming and keeping score, thinking unkind thoughts about the man at the bus stop. Sometimes people (including me) behave in ways that are disappointing or mean or desperate or worse - for reasons that are more complicated than I can quickly comprehend.
Which is easier? By refusing to respond to people in need, I could minimize the foolish factor and dole out my compassion and my pocket money to those I know with certainty are deserving. Or I could stop trying to control the outcome. Generosity should probably be freely offered or it turns into something else - something that generates as much joy and love and real relationship as paying the utility bill.
I'm still curious about his real story - which is probably every bit as layered and difficult as the fake one he sold to me a week ago. It has certainly been more interesting and challenging to have met and engaged this stranger than to have passed him by without even really seeing.
When you've been asked for help, when you've been surprised and disappointed - how have you responded?